Pros & Cons Of Refinancing Your Car Loan - FreedomCU (2024)

At times, it may be worthwhile to refinance a car loan. Doing so essentially replaces your current loan with a new one with possible benefits. However, there are also potential disadvantages to refinancing a car loan as well, but it ultimately depends on your situation.

Continue reading to learn about the pros and cons of refinancing a car.

Potential Pros Of Refinancing Your Car Loan

Some of the benefits of refinancing an auto loan include the possibility for better interest rates, shorter terms, or lower monthly payments.

Getting a better interest rate

One of the most common reasons to refinance a car loan is to get a better interest rate. Market rates fluctuate up and down over time, presenting opportunities to save on interest as time progresses.

Also, if you have been on time with all of your monthly payments, your credit score has likely improved. That can get you better rates from lenders since you present less risk to them.

Making car payments more manageable

Another advantage of refinancing is the potential to make car payments more manageable. If your finances are a bit tight right now, refinancing while market rates are down can get you slightly lower monthly payments by reducing interest.

Additionally, it is possible—though not always advised—to refinance to a longer loan term. Doing so can dramatically decrease your monthly payments, making them more manageable.

Paying off your car loan sooner

On the other hand, if you have more income—or less debt—than you did when you first bought your car, you can refinance to a shorter loan term to pay it off sooner. This offers a few advantages, one of which being that you won’t have to pay as much total interest over the life of the loan since it will have less time to accrue.

Another benefit of paying off your loan sooner is the fact that you can avoid getting upside down (or underwater) in the loan. Being upside down in a car loan means that you owe more on the loan than the car is worth. Given that vehicles depreciate over time, that can be a massive benefit, especially if you want to resell the vehicle later or if it gets totaled in an accident.

Paying off debts sooner also frees up income and lifts a burden off your shoulders.

Potential Cons Of Refinancing Your Car Loan

While refinancing can be beneficial when done under the right circ*mstances, there are some potential drawbacks involved. These are especially prevalent where an auto loan is refinanced at the wrong time.

More interest overall

In situations where you refinance to a longer loan term to get lower monthly payments, you may end up paying the price of more interest over the life of the loan. A longer loan term means interest has more time to accrue, so even if you get a lower annual percentage rate, adding 12 extra months could still end up outweighing the benefits long-term.

As such, it’s generally best to avoid refinancing to a longer car loan unless you have to.

Fees

Many lenders assess various fees on refinanced loans. Those fees may include early repayment penalties on the former loan, closing fees, transfer fees, and so on. It’s worth noting, however, that not every lender charges the same fees on their loans, so it’s often a good idea to look around for the best offer when it comes to refinancing a car loan.

If there are fees involved, it doesn’t necessarily mean that refinancing is a bad idea. The advantages of refinancing your car loan simply have to outweigh the costs.

Ending up underwater in the loan

One of the greatest risks of refinancing a car loan is the possibility of ending up underwater in the loan. By refinancing, you may extend the life of the loan (though that’s not always the case), which increases the chances that your car will depreciate below what you currently owe.

It’s for this reason that lenders may not even approve car loan refinancing if your vehicle is over a certain age. Different lenders have different policies, so again, shopping around may be a good idea.

When Is It Best To Refinance Your Car Loan?

Given the potential pros and cons of refinancing a car loan, the decision of whether to do so comes down to the timing and your current situation. Some scenarios in which refinancing might make sense include the following.

Your credit has improved

If your credit score has improved since taking out your loan, you may be able to save on interest—both short and long-term—by refinancing. In this case, it’s worth doing some calculations to see what your savings would be and if they warrant refinancing.

Interest rates have dropped

Additionally, if interest rates are at a low point, it presents a good opportunity for those who qualify for auto loan refinancing. Again, the potential for savings should be weighed against any costs and fees involved in refinancing.

It’s still early in the loan

The longer you’ve been paying off a car loan, the less the benefit will be if you refinance, and the higher the odds of going underwater. Often, lenders won’t even approve refinancing on an older car loan. Because of this, the earlier you refinance, the higher the potential benefits will be.

Weighing The Pros And Cons Of Refinancing A Car Loan

If you feel like refinancing might be a good option for you at this time, the first step is to talk to your lender. A credit union can help you determine if auto loan refinancing is the right move and guide you through the process.

Learn More About Refinancing Your Car Loan

Pros & Cons Of Refinancing Your Car Loan - FreedomCU (2024)

FAQs

Pros & Cons Of Refinancing Your Car Loan - FreedomCU? ›

Cons of refinancing your car loan

If you refinance to a longer-term car loan, you may pay more interest over the life of the new loan, even if you secure a lower rate. And finding low rates for long-term loans can be difficult. For example, say you have a 36-month, $15,000 auto loan with an 11 percent APR.

What is the downside to refinancing a car loan? ›

Cons of refinancing your car loan

If you refinance to a longer-term car loan, you may pay more interest over the life of the new loan, even if you secure a lower rate. And finding low rates for long-term loans can be difficult. For example, say you have a 36-month, $15,000 auto loan with an 11 percent APR.

Does refinancing your car look bad on your credit? ›

Refinancing may lower your credit score a few points, but the impact to your credit score will only be temporary. Applying for a loan generates a hard inquiry. Refinancing may be worth it if rates have dropped since you took out your loan.

Why do I owe more after refinancing my car? ›

If interest rates are higher than they were when the former loan originated, it may lead to owing more than you did under the previous loan. Refinancing may involve fees such as origination or document fees and prepayment charges, which can add to the overall amount you owe on the loan.

Do you need a down payment when you refinance a car? ›

Key takeaways. Refinancing does not require a down payment. However, you may be on the hook for fees like prepayment penalties or transaction fees. If you want to refinance a loan, you'll need equity in the car, a stable or better credit score and a current loan that fits lender refinancing requirements.

What to avoid when refinancing a car? ›

If it seems right for you, make sure you avoid these common mistakes when it comes to refinancing so you can maximize your savings.
  1. Drawing It Out. While it may seem tempting to switch to a longer loan term, it usually isn't worth it in the long run. ...
  2. Going Upside-Down. ...
  3. Catching Penalties. ...
  4. Missing Payments. ...
  5. Waiting Too Long.

Does refinancing a car actually save you money? ›

Refinancing and extending your loan term can lower your payments and keep more money in your pocket each month — but you may pay more in interest in the long run. On the other hand, refinancing to a lower interest rate at the same or shorter term as you have now will help you pay less overall.

What disqualifies you from refinancing a car? ›

A lender may not approve you for a refinance unless you meet a certain loan-to-value ratio (LTV). The LTV is the loan amount divided by the appraised value of your car. Check if you'll meet this requirement by finding the value of your car using online resources.

Why no one will refinance my car? ›

A lender might refuse to refinance a car if your current loan is too new, if your car is too old or has too many miles on it, or if your current loan balance is too low or too high.

When you refinance a vehicle, do you have to pay taxes again? ›

You Typically Don't Have to Pay Taxes on a Refinanced Car

This is because the vehicle isn't being sold as part of the refinancing process. You are still the owner of the vehicle, even though a lender holds a lien on it. All that is changing is the financial institution holding the lien on your vehicle.

What is a good interest rate for a car? ›

Car Loan APRs by Credit Score

Excellent (750 - 850): 2.96 percent for new, 3.68 percent for used. Good (700 - 749): 4.03 percent for new, 5.53 percent for used. Fair (650 - 699): 6.75 percent for new, 10.33 percent for used. Poor (450 - 649): 12.84 percent for new, 20.43 percent for used.

Do I lose my warranty if I refinance my car? ›

Breathe easy—if you're considering refinancing your car, you'll be glad to know that most manufacturer warranties will remain in effect. Refinancing your auto loan can be a smart move to lower your interest rate and monthly payments, and it shouldn't interfere with your car's existing warranty.

Am I better off refinancing vs making extra payments? ›

It all depends on your financial situation. Refinancing can make sense if you will hit the break-even point sooner rather than later. But if you have the money to do it, making extra payments on your mortgage could help you save money without needing to refinance.

What fees do you pay when refinancing a car? ›

Your state may charge fees to re-register your car or transfer the title. And your refinance lender could have application or origination fees. Your current lender might also charge a prepayment penalty for paying your loan off early, although prepayment fees aren't as common as they used to be.

Which bank is best for refinancing a car? ›

Compare the Best Auto Refinance Loans
CompanyInterest Rate
Best Overall: PenFed Credit Union5.44%-6.79% (new); 6.49%-7.54% (used)
Best Big Bank: PNC Bank6.84%–13.49%
Best Refinance Loan Marketplace: AUTOPAYAs low as 4.67%
Best Credit Union: Consumers Credit UnionStarting at 6.54%
2 more rows

What is a good credit score to refinance a car? ›

There is no minimum credit score required to refinance a car loan. That being said, there is a range that is considered a “good credit score” to refinance a car loan. In general, a credit score over 700 will unlock the best interest rates, and a credit score between 660-700 will give you access to standard rates.

What is the negative side of refinancing? ›

Con: Refinancing takes time.

It takes a lot of resources, time, and money, to secure a lower rate. This can be taxing on your life, especially if you don't see a large change in payments or interest.

How long should you wait to refinance your car? ›

While you might find more favorable rates advertised soon after you buy your new or used car, the downswing in your credit score means you probably won't get as favorable a rate as you would if you waited for your score to recover. The general advice is to wait at least six months before refinancing your auto loan.

Does refinancing a car restart your loan? ›

Refinancing does start your auto loan over. When you refinance a car loan, you choose a new loan that has a different rate and possibly a different term. The new loan replaces your current loan. Refinance terms offered by lenders most commonly are from two to seven years.

How does refinancing a car lower your payment? ›

Refinancing to a lower interest rate will decrease your monthly car payment some, but to significantly reduce your payment, you might have to extend your loan term. Going with a longer term can be a negative since you'll most likely pay more interest over the life of the loan.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Dan Stracke

Last Updated:

Views: 5851

Rating: 4.2 / 5 (63 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dan Stracke

Birthday: 1992-08-25

Address: 2253 Brown Springs, East Alla, OH 38634-0309

Phone: +398735162064

Job: Investor Government Associate

Hobby: Shopping, LARPing, Scrapbooking, Surfing, Slacklining, Dance, Glassblowing

Introduction: My name is Dan Stracke, I am a homely, gleaming, glamorous, inquisitive, homely, gorgeous, light person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.